Korean companies call for easing in auditor system four years after adoption
이 글자크기로 변경됩니다.
(예시) 가장 빠른 뉴스가 있고 다양한 정보, 쌍방향 소통이 숨쉬는 다음뉴스를 만나보세요. 다음뉴스는 국내외 주요이슈와 실시간 속보, 문화생활 및 다양한 분야의 뉴스를 입체적으로 전달하고 있습니다.
The Korea Chamber of Commerce and Industry (KCCI) announced on Wednesday that it submitted its opinion to the Financial Services Commission that demands abolition of the auditor rotation system.
“Auditor rotation undermines audit quality and only adds to the burden of companies as it is solely focused on strengthening independence such as breaking collusion between auditors and auditees,” KCCI said.
Under the system, the Securities and Futures Commission of the FSC appoints a new auditor for the next three years if a company has appointed the same auditor for six years. It was introduced to prevent companies from manipulating their accounts while being audited by the same auditor for a long time. The system took effect in 2019 and started applying from fiscal year 2020.
There are concerns that easing the restriction just four years after it was introduced may eventually make the system obsolete. The FSC plans to hear feedback through its accounting reform evaluation board established last year.
The business circle agrees that auditor rotation helps improve auditors’ independence but maintains that mandatory designation of auditors comes with social cost as it could undermine the qualifications of auditors and discourage competition. They say the system has to be abolished or improved to capture expertise, not just independence.
The idea is that corporate transparency can be enhanced better through whistleblowing, stricter supervision and audit committee activities. The KCCI says that even the U.S. does not require firms to rotate auditors and the U.K. focuses on improvement through market forces with reinforced supervision of accounting firms and renewed monitoring schemes.
Nevertheless, many criticize that changing a system that greatly improved accounting transparency in the last four years will have more downsides than upsides.
They are concerned that returning to the past will harm institutional stability when, in fact, strengthening the accounting system is needed in light of the recent embezzlement cases at Osstem Implant Co. and Woori Bank last year.
Overseas investment banks, which can be relatively objective on the scene, are also positive about mandatory auditor rotation.
At the end of last year, the Financial Supervisory Service revealed a policy to strengthen communication with market actors to improve auditor rotation and disclosed the result of its meeting with industrial members. Overseas investment banks are known to have said at the meeting that auditor rotation has a positive impact on improving the weak governance of Korean companies and enhancing accounting transparency although it may not be prevalent in other countries.
Overseas investment banks said the system helped relieve the “Korea discount,” which refers to a tendency for Korean companies to have lower valuations than global peers due to factors such as the dominance of opaque conglomerates and low dividend payouts.
“Mitigating or abolishing systems aimed at accounting transparency is not compatible with creating a good environment to do business,” said an unidentified official from the accounting industry. “Korea’s accounting transparency ranking is rising from the bottom, but it is still below mid-level and the system has to be retained to keep up with Korea’s national status that has scores of global companies.”
Copyright © 매일경제 & mk.co.kr. 무단 전재, 재배포 및 AI학습 이용 금지
- “유명 맛집 수상하다 했는데”…타코야키에 마약 넣다니 日 ‘발칵’ - 매일경제
- “처가에서 내 축의금 안돌려줘”…파혼 고민하는 신랑 - 매일경제
- “돈 왜 안모이나 봤더니”…月95만원 세금·이자냈다 ‘역대 최대’ - 매일경제
- “이러니 결혼 안한다하지”…청년 5명중 1명 소득 3배 ‘빚더미’ - 매일경제
- “역시 오빠차 전설, 더 멋져”…3월출시 신형 아반떼, 뭐가 달라졌을까 [카슐랭] - 매일경제
- “이 아파트 시장 사는데”…주차장 통로 막은 마이바흐, 왜? - 매일경제
- 진중권, 정순신 아들 학폭에 “애비나 자식이나 인간 쓰레기” - 매일경제
- “집안 망하게 생겼다”...상가 분양자들 패닉에 빠졌다는데 [매부리레터] - 매일경제
- “요즘 돈되는 테마? 바로 이것”…주식초고수, 로봇주 찍었다 - 매일경제
- 이정후는 사실상 확정 WBC, ML 쇼케이스는 김혜성 무대다 - MK스포츠