[Editorial] Conservative outlets need to stop claiming that prosecuting a chaebol head is attacking the company
이 글자크기로 변경됩니다.
(예시) 가장 빠른 뉴스가 있고 다양한 정보, 쌍방향 소통이 숨쉬는 다음뉴스를 만나보세요. 다음뉴스는 국내외 주요이슈와 실시간 속보, 문화생활 및 다양한 분야의 뉴스를 입체적으로 전달하고 있습니다.
After Samsung Electronics Vice Chairman Lee Jae-yong was taken into legal custody on Jan. 18, the majority of the South Korean press once again trumpeted claims of a “crisis at the Samsung Group.” These newspapers seem terrified that Lee’s incarceration will create major problems both for management at Samsung and for the national economy as a whole.
These papers both reject the legal judgment of the court and claim that the “victim” was sent to prison. Such behavior is witnessed whenever the head of a chaebol faces legal judgment, but this time around the strained arguments are particularly farfetched.
In an editorial on Jan. 19, the Chosun Ilbo claimed that “an extortion case was turned into a bribery case” and lamented the “fate of businesspeople” who are trying to keep their balance as they “walk along the top of a prison wall.”
Korea’s business newspapers adopted a similar stance. The Korea Economic Daily said that “politics has put a businessperson in jail,” while the Seoul Economic Daily said that “businesspeople should not be sacrificed for political power.” Such claims suggest that Lee was prosecuted as some kind of sacrificial lamb to political power.
These articles repeat verbatim Lee’s argument that he wasn’t the person giving a bribe but the victim of extortion, and they fully reject the legal decision confirmed by the Supreme Court.
Newspapers that are so quick to talk about “the rule of law” can’t even seem to remember “equality before the law” when confronted with the head of a chaebol. They should be ashamed of themselves.
The high court that tried Lee’s case, which had been thrown back by the Supreme Court, said that Lee had “aggressively bribed” Park and “implicitly requested that Park use her presidential authority to aid his succession” to control the Samsung Group. The court found that Lee had embezzled company money to give Park a bribe, so that she would help him assume management rights over the group.
Lee committed this illegal act for his own personal benefit, not even for corporate profit. The victims here are Samsung the corporation and its executives, employees and stockholders.
A chaebol corporation is not the personal possession of the chaebol head. It’s outrageous to misrepresent the prosecution of a chaebol head as an attack on that corporation.
Many have also argued that Lee’s imprisonment will create a crisis in the management of Samsung’s global operations, including its operations in new industries and large-scale investments. But there’s little evidence to back up such exaggerated claims.
Samsung’s performance improved in 2017 when Lee was in jail
Samsung Electronics’ business performance improved markedly in 2017, even as Lee was in jail. Claims that Lee’s imprisonment will ultimately cause serious harm to the national economy are even more absurd.
Are those pundits seriously arguing that illegal acts by chaebol heads should be forever placed outside the bounds of Korean courts’ jurisdiction, and all that for the national economy? That’s not just absurd — it’s a malicious attempt to hoodwink the public.
The time has come to set aside these anachronistic attempts to muddy the waters about chaebol heads’ corruption and illegality by stirring up groundless panic. If these newspapers are genuinely worried about Samsung, they should encourage Lee to keep his promise about abiding by the law in corporate management, and watch carefully to see whether he actually does so.
Please direct comments or questions to [english@hani.co.kr]
Copyright © 한겨레신문사 All Rights Reserved. 무단 전재, 재배포, AI 학습 및 활용 금지
- 문 대통령 “코로나 백신 2천만명분 추가 확보 길 열려”
- 노숙인에게 점퍼 벗어준 시민 사진에 “따뜻한 마음에 언 땅 눈 녹듯”
- “두렵지만 누군가는 해야…” 임상 참가자 헌신이 1년만에 백신 만들었다
- 복싱용 샌드백에 밀수한 1.3톤 담뱃잎이 호주로 간 까닭은?
- [숨&결] 신아원으로 다시 보내진 이들 / 배복주
- 방사청 ‘핵추진 무인 잠수모함’ 미래 무기로 제안
- 여성 장관 비율 16%대로 주저앉아…‘30% 공약’은 헛말?
- 이장 자리가 뭐길래…주민 20명 하낙월도 원정투표 논란
- ‘확진자 밀접접촉’ 박근혜 전 대통령, 코로나 음성 판정
- [만리재사진첩] 12컷 사진으로 돌아본 ‘코로나 1년’